Let’s get physical! On-site appraisals for the win!

Before Covid-19, there was no question as to how appraisals were performed. An appraiser visited the site where the items of appraisal are located, did their work, then wrote up a report and submitted it to the person for whom the appraisal report was prepared.

Enter the pandemic and a world under lockdown. Online appraisals were already a thing, but as people turned to the internet for the sake of safety and convenience, they surged in popularity.

Online appraisals do have their niche but they are extremely limited. A major part of the appraiser’s role is the ability to physically examine items. Condition is often paramount, so damage or areas of repair are the first things I look – and feel, smell and listen – for. (So far I haven’t had yet to taste an appraisal item, though I’ve been known to rub a questionable pearl over my teeth 🙂

Let’s say you want to get Granny’s Minton Haddon Hall tea set appraised prior to selling it online. You find an online appraisal site offering a quick turnaround time, upload the information you have and attach photos of the tea set. If you are absolutely certain that every single piece of the tea set is in perfect condition, your measurements are accurate and photos sharp and crystal clear and you’ve included legible maker’s marks, you should be fine.

However, if you aren’t used to looking for flaws or repairs, or send poor quality images, then you are compromising the appraisal’s integrity. The online appraiser can only go on what you give them. No responsible appraiser will make assumptions about an item.

Not too long ago I watched an episode of Antiques Roadshow where a painting had been appraised online for $1500. The AR appraiser valued the same painting in the range of $15 000. Even taking into account market fluctuation, that is a considerable difference!

That’s all for this week’s blog. If you have any questions, feel free to get in touch with me via the Contact form. Have a good week!

Similar Posts

  • Vintage….dogs?

    Perhaps the most important aspect of my appraising career it taking the pulse of the culture in which I live. This is done just by living and taking note of what I see. Though I wouldn’t call myself a dog aficionado, I have some dog buddies and we are always happy to see each other….

  • Thoroughness pays off!

    Sirop d’erable. Liquid gold. Magic tree sauce. Whatever else you may choose to call it by, maple syrup is indisputably linked with Canada. Many people know of the staggering amount of work that goes into turning the sap or late winter and early spring into delicious, wonderful syrup. As with most things in life, the…

  • Ruminations

    Ruminating. It can mean ‘to think deeply about something’, or to ‘chew the cud’. Currently between assignments, I keep my appraisal knowledge honed by reading up on the latest trends in the markets, covering everything from farm equipment to fine art. And when the opportunity to practice very basic art conservation work crops up, I…

  • Bully for you!

    “Hey, you’re British, aren’t you?” I was at McHaffie’s Flea Market and know many of the vendors. One of them was asking that question. I said yes, and he asked if I knew anything about John Bull. It isn’t unusual for vendors to ask my assistance in identifying an item or, in this case, giving…

  • The Sweet Spot

    It’s no secret that I do perform occasional quid pro quo work for a few select people. They are antique store owners, flea market vendors, and private individuals with certain specialties. It is their expertise that I call upon when I want to verify something, or need to fill gaps in my knowledge. In return,…